Join Chalkbeat New York’s free day by day e-newsletter to get important information about NYC’s public faculties delivered to your inbox.
The abrupt dismissal of a Brooklyn superintendent is spurring fierce backlash in Bedford-Stuyvesant, the place dozens of group members confirmed as much as a city corridor assembly Monday evening to specific their outrage.
Colleges Chancellor Melissa Aviles-Ramos eliminated District 16 Superintendent Brendan Mims on Monday, based on state Meeting member Stefani Zinerman, who spoke with Aviles-Ramos and arranged Monday’s city corridor. The precise causes for the elimination are unclear. However in a Monday letter to Aviles-Ramos recapping their current discussions about Mims, Zinerman attributed the issues to a “breakdown within the relationship” between Mims and the native Group Training Council, an elected mother or father advisory board, based on a replica of the letter shared with Chalkbeat.
Mims’ interim alternative, former Deputy Superintendent Fabayo McIntosh, took over Tuesday, based on an electronic mail to principals obtained by Chalkbeat.
The elimination of Mims is likely one of the first main personnel strikes for Aviles-Ramos, who assumed her position in October and has largely emphasised her need to keep up the insurance policies of her predecessor, David Banks. The transfer might now embroil Aviles-Ramos in a public battle at a fragile second in her tenure, as she rolls out her personal first coverage efforts and as her future stays unsure with Mayor Eric Adams going through a steep climb to win reelection on this 12 months’s mayoral race.
The chancellor’s determination — and its timing over spring break — got here as a shock to Zinerman and the handfuls of educators, mother and father, and group leaders who confirmed as much as the swiftly organized Monday assembly within the basement of the Restoration Plaza group middle. Audio system heaped reward onto Mims, a 22-year veteran of the town Training Division, for his group engagement and robust educational observe report.
“I’ve been a principal for over 26 years, lengthy sufficient to see the modifications which have occurred in District 16,” mentioned Lena Gates, the veteran chief of P.S. 5, an elementary college within the district, and one among a number of principals who confirmed up on the city corridor to assist Mims. “When Brendan Mims got here to District 16, I mentioned, ‘We lastly acquired it proper…’ I’m actually so upset to listen to what’s taking place.”
Attendees mentioned the timing of the transfer additionally appeared like an effort to sneak it via with out discover.
“That’s an absolute shame, and it’s disrespectful,” mentioned Zinerman, whose meeting district largely overlaps with District 16. “I’ve been elected since 2010, and I’ve not had the chance to chain myself to a door but. That is the door that I’m going to chain myself to.”
Zinerman added that making the choice towards the tip of the college 12 months as college students put together to take state exams and at a second of profound uncertainty for metropolis faculties due to federal threats to schooling might destabilize the district.
Training Division spokesperson Nicole Brownstein mentioned the “superintendency is an appointed place and an at-will rent” who serves on the pleasure of the chancellor. She mentioned the company will observe the chancellor’s laws governing the appointment of a brand new everlasting superintendent, which embody consulting with the CEC and educators unions.
Within the electronic mail to principals saying the change, Deputy Chancellor of College Management Danika Rux praised McIntosh as a “seasoned educator” and “proud product of District 16.”
“We lengthen because of Brendan for his service to District 16,” Rux added.
Mims couldn’t be reached for remark. NeQuan McLean, the long-time president of CEC 16, who lately appeared on stage with Aviles-Ramos to announce a brand new program for mother or father volunteers, declined to remark, and different members of the CEC didn’t reply to emails.
Banks employed Mims in 2022 as a part of a sweeping shakeup of the town’s 45 superintendent positions. The trouble was meant to vest the position of superintendent with extra accountability, particularly in finishing up Banks’s literacy curriculum overhaul, and to present communities extra enter within the number of their district leaders.
That group enter is very vital in District 16 — the neighborhood that helped beginning the group management motion within the Nineteen Sixties the place Black and Puerto Rican group members established the Ocean Hill-Brownsville district that finally sparked the 1968 trainer strike.
That historical past echoed via Monday evening’s assembly.
“That is our group, and we make the choices close to who’s main, particularly with our kids,” mentioned Marlon Rice, the occasions director at Restoration Plaza.
Mims took over a district confronting challenges
Regardless of its storied historical past, District 16 has confronted steep challenges in current a long time, together with enrollment losses stemming from inhabitants declines, notably amongst Black households, in central Brooklyn and the proliferation of constitution faculties.
Earlier this 12 months, Mims, a Brooklyn native, efficiently shepherded a plan to shutter P.S. 25, the town’s smallest elementary college with simply 53 college students — an concept district officers first tried seven years in the past however didn’t get accepted.
Individuals who attended Monday’s assembly pointed to Mims’ management as a vibrant spot amid these challenges, pushing the district ahead academically whereas bringing the group on board.
The district’s proficiency charges on state English exams for grades 3-8 rose from 37% in 2022 to 44% final 12 months, and from 25% to 44% in math for a similar grades — bigger than the town’s total progress in each circumstances.
Mims additionally performed an enormous position in bringing a brand new Black Research curriculum to the district, the place roughly 64% of scholars are Black, educators mentioned.
Leaders of nonprofits and native companies mentioned Mims was unusually energetic in getting them concerned, and one district father spoke glowingly about an off-the-cuff group of dads Mims led.
“I by no means met a superintendent earlier than, by no means had nobody come out and say let’s meet and greet, we’re doing one thing particular for the dads,” mentioned Jason Smith, a mother or father within the district. “He was all the time involved with how can we enhance… that is one thing that’s hitting arduous.”
Tensions emerge with native mother or father council
Zinerman mentioned she began getting wind final 12 months of rigidity between Mims and the native CEC — and mentioned there was a sample over greater than a decade of superintendents solely lasting just a few years within the district due to “political or interpersonal battle.”
“What started as enthusiastic assist — heralding Mr. Mims as ‘precisely the person we want’ — has devolved into distrust,” Zinerman wrote in her Monday letter to Aviles-Ramos.
Zinerman mentioned she met with Aviles-Ramos and several other of her high deputies final Wednesday to debate the state of affairs and urged the town to nominate an unbiased mediator to resolve the dispute between Mims and the CEC.
Zinerman mentioned she thought division officers have been on the identical web page and was shocked to get a name round midday on Monday from Aviles-Ramos telling her that Mims was out and his alternative would begin the following day.
Zinerman instructed attendees at Monday’s assembly that Mims was reassigned to the Training Division’s suspension listening to workplace, drawing jeers from the group. (An Training Division spokesperson didn’t verify Mims’ new task). Analysis has proven that Black male educators are extra prone to be shunted into disciplinary roles, and Black college students within the 5 boroughs are disproportionately suspended.
“What they need to do is ship this Black man to the suspension middle, the place all of the Black boys go,” mentioned Barry Cooper, a group chief who runs a program supporting boys of colour. “That is academic negligence.”
Cooper pledged to proceed organizing protests all through this week, with city corridor attendees committing to calling Mayor Adams, displaying up on the native district workplace, and rallying on the Training Division headquarters in Manhattan.
“It is a precipice for us to take management of our group and be a beacon like Mattress-Stuy has all the time been,” Cooper mentioned.
Alex Zimmerman contributed.
Michael Elsen-Rooney is a reporter for Chalkbeat New York, masking NYC public faculties. Contact Michael at [email protected]
