Join Chalkbeat Colorado’s free each day e-newsletter to get the most recent reporting from us, plus curated information from different Colorado shops, delivered to your inbox.
Vilas College District RE-5 in southeastern Colorado has 50 college students, 25 workers, and is 60 miles from the closest grocery store. Housing is so scarce that the just lately employed elementary college principal was dwelling in a faculty board member’s basement, on a cattle and wheat farm, whereas the district renovated a cellular house it owns for her and her daughter.
“Vilas is out in the midst of nowhere,” a brand new report on rural Colorado trainer salaries says. “That fits many residents simply wonderful, however it may pose a problem when making an attempt to recruit lecturers from exterior the neighborhood.”
Pay is one other barrier. The common trainer wage in Vilas for the 2023-24 college 12 months was $39,775 – almost $30,000 lower than the state common.
Vilas RE-5 is without doubt one of the districts featured within the report launched by the Keystone Coverage Heart Wednesday known as “Inadequate at any altitude: Rural trainer salaries in Colorado.”
The report concludes that top mounted prices, low property wealth, lengthy commutes, and lower-than-average pay make it tough for small rural college districts to rent and retain lecturers. That’s an issue as a result of analysis reveals having high-quality lecturers is without doubt one of the most dependable methods to spice up pupil achievement, the report says.
One of many variables examined within the report — excessive mounted prices for small rural districts — is commonly missed, the report says. Nevertheless it provides up.
“If a faculty roof springs a leak or an HVAC system goes down, discovering a restore firm or particular person prepared to make the drive could be a main chore, and provides considerably to the expense,” the report says. “The dearth of competitors for such companies additionally tends to drive up the value.”
Whereas city and suburban districts with decrease mounted prices can spend as a lot as 90% of their budgets on salaries, small rural districts can solely spend 60% to 65%, the report finds. The common trainer salaries in small rural districts have been under $55,000 in 2023-24, the report finds, whereas lecturers within the Denver metro space made greater than $78,000 on common.
“It’s turning into a much bigger and greater difficulty for varsity districts in rural communities to have the ability to rent and retain of us,” stated Van Schoales, a senior coverage director on the Keystone Coverage Heart and co-author of the report. “Wage isn’t the one factor, but it surely’s a extremely necessary piece of it.”
The report recommends Colorado convene a activity power to review how different states, together with neighboring New Mexico, have handed legal guidelines mandating minimal trainer salaries. It additionally suggests Colorado contemplate altering its college funding formulation to direct extra {dollars} to districts that battle to supply aggressive wages.
The report recommends establishing a brand new grant program for districts resembling Vilas RE-5 that may’t increase property taxes to spice up college district income. Within the absence of extra funding, the report recommends giving lecturers different perks, resembling sponsored housing.
“Whereas many years of analysis demonstrates that many variables have an effect on the standard of a pupil’s schooling, a constant theme is the significance of high-quality lecturers in offering college students a top-flight schooling with robust outcomes,” the report says.
Utilizing common trainer wage knowledge printed by the Colorado Division of Training, the report zeroes in on districts that serve what the state classifies as “outlying cities,” the place most college students stay in inhabitants facilities of between 1,000 and seven,000 folks, and “distant” areas, the place college students are scattered as a result of there isn’t any inhabitants heart.
The report concludes that common trainer salaries range broadly in these districts however are nonetheless decrease than what lecturers are paid within the Denver metro space and in different cities and suburbs.
Though the price of dwelling is decrease in outlying cities and distant areas, it’s not low sufficient to make it extra reasonably priced than educating in a metropolis or suburb, the report says. It finds that “lecturers have much less shopping for energy in rural areas on common when adjusted for price of dwelling.”
The report quotes Karl Van Syckle, who moved from Utah to Colorado to show within the Montezuma-Cortez College District. It says his take-home pay was $39,800 final 12 months.
“That pays hire, gasoline, and groceries, with possibly $400 or $500 left over each month,” Van Syckle is quoted as saying. “It has been tremendous arduous. My automobile has 147,000 miles on it. I’ve to hope it retains working as a result of I can’t afford a automobile cost.”
Melanie Asmar is the bureau chief for Chalkbeat Colorado. Contact Melanie at [email protected].
