Join Chalkbeat Indiana’s free every day e-newsletter to maintain up with Indianapolis Public Faculties, Marion County’s township districts, and statewide training information.
Within the spring of 2024, monetary challenges at Bethel Park Elementary prompted the mayor’s workplace to stipulate choices for its future — together with a partnership with neighboring constitution college Victory Faculty Prep.
The college’s board didn’t wish to try this on the time, in line with the varsity’s former principal. As a substitute, the varsity labored to reply to considerations from Mayor Joe Hogsett’s Workplace of Schooling Innovation, Bethel Park’s authorizer.
Now issues are coming to a head. OEI nonetheless has considerations about Bethel Park’s monetary standing and will revoke the varsity’s constitution subsequent month, a transfer that might lead the varsity to shut. However the college says it’s proven OEI that its fiscal well being is on the mend. And it seems that there’s one other large change within the works: Victory Faculty Prep is within the course of of shopping for Bethel Park’s constructing.
All that has thrown the destiny of Bethel Park — which enrolls about 225 college students whose futures grasp on OEI’s mid-February resolution — into doubt. And a few consider the chain of occasions represents an unwelcome try to power the varsity to merge with a close-by competitor.
“It does kind of really feel like a conclusion has already been made,” mentioned former Bethel Park principal Jennica Adkins, who mentioned there was stress from OEI on Bethel Park to merge with Victory Faculty Prep this college yr. “And there’s not a ton that we will do about that.”
OEI acknowledged approaching Victory Faculty Prep to “gauge their curiosity and talent to supply help” to Bethel Park Elementary.
“Constitution college authorizers have a accountability to work with colleges to anticipate points earlier than they intensify to make sure stability for college kids and accountable stewardship of public {dollars},” the workplace mentioned in a press release final month in response to questions from Chalkbeat.
OEI additionally mentioned Bethel Park has utilized for constitution renewal after “years of declining monetary well being and amid months of intensifying money stream considerations.”
As an authorizer of each Bethel Park and Victory Faculty Prep, OEI oversees colleges which were granted permission to open by the Indianapolis Constitution Faculty Board. It additionally has the energy to shutter colleges for failing to fulfill sure requirements.
“High quality authorizing practices encourage authorizers to train skilled judgment and interact in efforts to drawback clear up when wanted to make sure good outcomes for college kids,” OEI mentioned in its assertion.
In response, Bethel Park’s board is choices to buy the constructing as an alternative, utilizing an choice in its present lease with a department of the Constitution Faculties Growth Company that funds amenities for constitution colleges. Bethel Park’s present constitution expires on the finish of this college yr, however the college is looking for approval from a distinct authorizer than OEI to maintain its doorways open. Nevertheless, if their constitution is revoked subsequent month, state regulation would require a brand new authorizer to hunt approval from the State Board of Schooling to permit the varsity to proceed working.
Jade Welch, Bethel Park’s present principal, mentioned she is working exhausting to handle the considerations from the mayor’s workplace whereas sustaining the varsity’s imaginative and prescient and neighborhood.
“I simply wish to preserve my college and do what I have to do,” Welch mentioned.
Victory Faculty Prep’s board of administrators didn’t point out whether or not it intends to take over Bethel Park, though it pressured that Bethel Park’s destiny is as much as the varsity and OEI to determine. The board mentioned it needs college students within the space to have entry to high-quality training, and that it was “open” to the concept of offering “partnership help” to Bethel Park.
“If our present sources and capability can ease monetary pressures that might threaten such entry for college kids and households in our area, we’re compelled to take motion,” Victory Faculty Prep’s board mentioned in a press release.
Faculty protests potential lack of constitution, citing enhancements
In Might 2023, the mayor’s workplace gave Bethel Park a discover of noncompliance — the least pressing degree within the authorizer’s efficiency enchancment framework — over its 2021-22 ILEARN and IREAD scores and its attendance charge. The college’s ILEARN scores had been beneath these of scholars in close by assigned colleges or comparable colleges, the workplace mentioned. The college’s IREAD go charge of 62% and its attendance charge of 87.6% additionally didn’t meet the workplace’s efficiency customary.
One yr later, the varsity obtained a discover of deficiency over its money reserves and year-end deficits that the workplace escalated from “reasonable” to “excessive” concern.
The college has resulted in an working deficit yearly since fiscal 2022, in line with audit experiences the varsity submitted to the state. The most recent audit from final yr expresses “substantial doubt” concerning the college’s capacity to remain open. And for the reason that 2020-21 college yr, the varsity had not met OEI’s necessities for conserving a minimum of 45 days of money reserve to be able to meet monetary obligations within the case of an emergency, in line with OEI.
However college leaders say they’ve tried to handle the authorizer’s considerations. And in an e-mail to OEI final July, Bethel Park’s board referred to as the authorizer’s’s escalating considerations “unwarranted” because of the college’s constructive money steadiness, and mentioned that “the varsity’s monetary place is not at excessive danger.”
Its first discover of deficiency from OEI was largely because of bookkeeping errors which were addressed, the varsity mentioned in a Dec. 19 response to the authorizer. Within the first few months of this college yr, the varsity spent much less cash and introduced in additional income than anticipated, Bethel Park famous. It believes it can construct up 40 to 45 days of money reserves by the tip of the fiscal yr.
And its enrollment of 225 this yr was above preliminary projections.
“We’ve got realized from and responded to previous monetary errors and oversight and really feel assured not solely in our capacity to complete out this college yr, but additionally to ascertain an ongoing monetary place which ought to encourage confidence in renewal of our constitution,” the varsity wrote.
Bethel Park has additionally lower prices to shore up its funds, together with ending a $150,000 annual teaching and consulting companies settlement with the PilotED Basis, which was led by the varsity’s founder, Jacob Allen.
The inspiration, which ended operations in December, supplied assist with grant writing, authorized help, board recruiting, and training, mentioned Adkins, the varsity’s former principal. The inspiration nonetheless supplied six months of labor professional bono after the expiration of its contract final June, she mentioned.
The college’s third grade IREAD outcomes have additionally jumped to a 72% go charge in 2024. Its attendance charge, nonetheless, stays slightly below the 90% that OEI requested it attain by summer time 2024, and its ILEARN outcomes have been stagnant.
OEI mentioned in its assertion that even with the correction of the bookkeeping error, the varsity nonetheless had posted years of declining money reserves, comparatively gradual enrollment development, and excessive month-to-month bills.
“All through the spring, summer time, and fall, Bethel Park needed to right a number of errors in submitted monetary paperwork and failed to fulfill a number of monetary reporting deadlines,” OEI mentioned. “In yr six of a faculty’s constitution, a robust authorizer ought to count on competent monetary reporting and administration.
Victory Faculty Prep, which the mayor’s workplace described as a faculty in “sturdy monetary standing,” didn’t disclose how a lot it’s paying for the constructing. The college had greater charges of proficiency on the 2024 ILEARN examination than Bethel Park, and a barely greater passing charge on the IREAD examination.
Amelia Pak-Harvey covers Indianapolis and Lawrence Township colleges for Chalkbeat Indiana. Contact Amelia at [email protected].
