Join Chalkbeat Chicago’s free day by day e-newsletter to maintain up with the newest information on Chicago Public Colleges.
Courtney Billittier comes from a protracted line of educators, together with her father who lately retired after 35 years of instructing. However Billittier, who has been instructing for the previous 14 years, must work longer than her father to earn a smaller pension.
That’s as a result of state lawmakers handed pension reform laws to take care of a funds disaster in 2010 that created new requirements for public sector staff employed initially of 2011. The result’s a two tiered pension system: Staff employed earlier than 2011 have been in a position to retire as early as age 55 and with extra monetary perks, whereas staff employed after that yr have been eligible to retire at age 67. That is sometimes called Tier 1 and Tier 2 advantages.
Billittier stated her father has at all times inspired her to have a separate retirement financial savings account due to the change in state legislation.
“I feel it actually ingrained in me instantly that I shouldn’t be banking on the pension on the finish of this profession being one thing that I can reside off of fully, and that there must be some actions that I’m taking alone,” stated Billittier.
Academics unions, together with the Illinois Federation of Academics and Illinois Schooling Affiliation, alongside different public sector worker unions are advocating for state lawmakers to make a change to retirement advantages for newer educators. They are saying it’s unfair to present educators who pay the identical quantity into the pension system however don’t obtain the identical advantages and must work longer. In addition they worry that the present system will deter new educators from coming into the occupation at a time when the state is fighting a trainer scarcity.
However there’s a fair greater situation: The decrease tier retirement advantages may quickly fall under what’s offered by Social Safety.
In Illinois, public college educators and different public sector staff don’t pay into Social Safety and are additionally not eligible to obtain these federal advantages after they retire. Nonetheless, Illinois should be certain that advantages are at the least equal to Social Safety.
The Civic Federation, a nonpartisan analysis group, stated state lawmakers must make a change to the tiered retirement advantages quickly or the state will danger falling out of compliance with federal legal guidelines, often known as Secure Harbor — a normal set by the Inner Income Service assessing a number of components to see if state pension advantages are equal to Social Safety advantages — which may very well be expensive for Illinois.
Illinois Sen. Robert Martwick, who has proposed laws prior to now and this yr to alter the trainer retirement advantages system, stated it may get costly for the state, native municipalities, and even college districts if the state’s pension programs don’t adjust to federal legislation. Martwick stated the decrease tier pension advantages may open college districts as much as expensive lawsuits — if lecturers prevailed, settlements may eat into districts’ working budgets.
“That might sink Illinois in a single day,” stated Martwick, including that failing to right the state of affairs will not be an possibility for the state.
Academics unions, state legislators, and finance consultants all agree that the decrease tier pension advantages have to be addressed. Nevertheless, they differ in how you can repair the issue. Listed below are 5 issues it is best to find out about Illinois’ two tier pension advantages and what they imply for educators and school rooms.
Why did Illinois create a second tier pension profit?
State pension funds have been hit arduous by the 2008 monetary disaster, usually referred to as the Nice Recession, since pension programs have investments within the inventory market. Public pensions throughout the nation noticed their investments fall in worth by $889 billion between 2007 and 2008, in response to numbers by the Federal Reserve.
Amanda Kass, assistant professor at DePaul College, stated the well being of the pension system determines how a lot cash the state and staff should contribute to the system to ensure that it to have cash to pay retirees. When the market crashed, the quantity Illinois lawmakers wanted to contribute went up considerably. To assist offset ballooning pension funds, state lawmakers handed a invoice in 2010 that modified retirement advantages for all public sector staff who began engaged on or after Jan. 1, 2011. They believed the plan would save the state cash over time.
Annie Rojas, lead coverage analyst on the Middle for Tax and Price range Accountability, stated the state’s pension issues began earlier than 2010. She pointed to coverage adjustments in 1995 below Republican Gov. Jim Edgar when the state created a pension ramp, often known as the Edgar Ramp, that might require the state to get pension funds to 90% funded by 2045. This ramp set the state’s pension contributions very low on the starting of the 50-year plan, resulting in greater pension prices in a while. In response to Crain’s Chicago Enterprise in 2010, the state was not contributing sufficient funding to the pension system even earlier than Edgar’s Ramp was created. Because the Eighties, lawmakers have minimize funding to pensions to take care of funds shortfalls.
Pension funds make up virtually 20% of the state’s proposed funds for fiscal yr 2026. The Academics Retirement System’s funded ratio is at 45.8% as of fiscal yr 2024.
What do Tier 2 pension advantages imply for educators?
All pension funds in Illinois have two tiers now. This contains the Trainer Retirement System, which covers all lecturers within the 800-plus college districts exterior of Chicago, and the Chicago Academics Pension Fund.
Al Llorens, president of the Illinois Schooling Affiliation, stated a key distinction between the 2 tiers is that lecturers within the second tier should work till age 67. For educators who may need began as a trainer proper out of faculty on the age of twenty-two, they must work about 45 years. Nevertheless, lecturers within the first tier may obtain retirement advantages at age 55, having labored for roughly 33 years.
As soon as lecturers in Tier 2 retire, their pensionable wage is capped and calculated otherwise than Tier 1 lecturers. That calculation takes their highest wage of eight years within the 10 years earlier than retiring, relatively than 4 of the final 10 years, which leads to a decrease remaining common wage, in response to the Civic Federation.
Whatever the distinction in advantages between the 2 tiers, all lecturers pay the identical quantity into the pension system, which Llorens stated is main lecturers to depart the occupation.
“Should you’re paying much more than what your pension is returning, that’s not an incentive to remain both,” stated Llorens. “We do must take care of one thing that not solely permits us to draw however to retain lecturers, as a result of we’re in the midst of a scarcity that doesn’t appear to be going away anytime quickly.“
May smaller retirement advantages steer folks away from the occupation?
It’s unclear whether or not smaller retirement advantages are steering folks away from the instructing occupation in Illinois. Nevertheless, finance consultants, educators, and lecturers union leaders imagine it may very well be a problem for hiring and retaining educators.
Tom Moore, a science trainer at Hoffman Property Excessive Faculty at Township Faculty District 211, who’s in Tier 2, stated he thinks it may very well be arduous to retain some educators who may not have realized they have been going to must work longer than a few of their colleagues.
“I’m 13 years in now, and I nonetheless have 35 extra years to go,” stated Moore. “At this level, if I used to be Tier 1, I might already be a 3rd away or virtually half the way in which by way of my skilled profession.”
Hiring and retaining lecturers are a significant concern for native college districts, particularly because the state is coping with a trainer scarcity. A joint report from the Illinois Affiliation of Regional Superintendents of Colleges and the Illinois State Board of Schooling discovered that the scarcity of lecturers is easing throughout the state, nevertheless it has been troublesome for districts to fill sure trainer positions, reminiscent of roles in particular schooling and bilingual schooling.
When schooling leaders have been requested in regards to the prime three points resulting in trainer shortages, 143 of the 694 leaders who responded stated it was because of issue hiring and retaining lecturers, in response to the report.
“Whereas the pay throughout their profession is probably not nice there was at all times a great retirement to work in direction of,” stated a quote within the report. “Now they don’t have both.”
Can the state undo its two tiered pension system?
The quick reply might be not. It will be costly for the state to place all of its lecturers and different public sector staff into Tier 1.
Pension prices for the state are already excessive: In fiscal yr 2025, pensions accounted for roughly 19% of the state’s total working funds. In response to a report by the College of Illinois’ Institute of Authorities and Public Affairs, it will price the state virtually $30 billion by fiscal yr 2045 to match Tier 2 retirement advantages to Tier 1. This could require the state so as to add $1.3 billion {dollars} to pensions by the top of 2027.
Annie McGowan from Civic Federation stated the state doesn’t “have the income stream” to make bigger funds to the pension system. Particularly at a time when there are different pressures on state funding.
Illinois’ pension system additionally may very well be affected by the dramatic decline within the inventory market that has adopted President Donald Trump saying tariffs, or taxes on items from different nations, final week. The final time the market took such a success was on the starting of the COVID pandemic in 2020.
What are the proposals to alter Tier 2?
State lawmakers, lecturers unions, finance and funds officers, and even Gov. J.B. Pritzker have totally different concepts for how you can enhance the trainer pension system. However all of them agree that the principle constraint is price.
The Civic Federation referred to as on the state in a report from 2023 to adjust to federal legal guidelines and make sure the second tier stays equal to or higher than Social Safety advantages. Rojas, from the Middle for Tax and Price range Accountability, stated compliance with federal legislation isn’t sufficient when the distinction in pension advantages between tiers is inequitable for staff.
The Illinois Educators Affiliation want to see the retirement age for Tier 2 staff decreased from 67 to 60 years previous — nonetheless greater than staff within the first tier — and a rise in retirement advantages, stated Llorens.
State lawmakers filed Home Invoice 2711 and Senate Invoice 2 to alter a part of Tier 2 on this spring’s legislative session. Martwick stated his proposal within the Senate will be certain that the state is in compliance with federal legislation and can make some adjustments requested by state worker unions. Nevertheless, he stated the invoice is more likely to change earlier than being voted on since there are ongoing negotiations round how you can tackle the lesser tier pension advantages.
Final yr, Pritzker introduced proposals to repair the state’s pension disaster. Amongst his plans have been to extend the funding objective to 100%, greater than the 90% accredited within the Nineteen Nineties, to make sure pensions are totally funded. Since shifting the funding goal would improve state pension contributions, Pritzker proposed shifting the goal yr to 2048, as a substitute of 2045.
Additionally, Pritzker needs to alter the state’s pensionable wage cap to match Social Safety to adjust to federal legislation. To attain this a part of the plan, Pritzker proposed an extra $78 million within the fiscal yr 2026 funds on prime of the state’s required contributions.
Samantha Smylie is the state schooling reporter for Chalkbeat Chicago overlaying college districts throughout the state, laws, particular schooling and the state board of schooling. Contact Samantha at [email protected].
